生态补偿的地理学特征及内涵研究

doi:10.11821/dlyj201405001

摘要/Abstract

摘要： 地理学以环境—社会—人类动态的综合思维，以区域综合、区域间的相互关系、尺度间的相互转换等系统研究地球表层的性质和运动规律，“人—地”地域系统是其研究核心。生态补偿是一个典型的地理学研究命题，具有“人—地”地域系统的半开放性、非稳定性以及或然性特征。本文分析了生态补偿作为地理学研究命题的一般特征及其内涵。对于生态补偿是一个地理学研究命题的判断，依据在于自然地域系统厘定了生态补偿参与主体的基本关系、经济地理格局决定了生态补偿的空间差异、地域人文环境影响了生态补偿政策的制定及其补偿形式、地理学方法为生态补偿提供了技术与平台。区域是解读生态补偿问题的突破口，区域结构是制定生态补偿政策的重要参考、区域发展外部性是开展生态补偿的科学依据、地理要素资源的区域权属是确定生态补偿主客体的依据，生态补偿研究具有“区域—差异—尺度”的地理学分析范式。生态补偿的地理学特征表现在区域性、差异性、综合性、动态性等方面。

关键词: 生态补偿, 地理学, 特征, 内涵, &ldquo, 人&mdash, 地&rdquo, 地域系统

Abstract: Geography studies the nature and movement law of earth surface in a systematic way that involves perspectives of regional differentiation, regional interactions, a synthesis of environmental, societal and human dynamics, and interdependence between spatial scales. The discipline takes human-land territorial system (HLTS) as its hard core of studies. This paper argues that eco-compensation is a typical geographical issue and presents similar features of the HLTS, such as semi-opening, instability and random. Based on such an argument, the paper examines the geographical features and implications of eco-compensation. First, the physical side of the HLTS determines the fundamental relationships between different stakeholders in eco-compensation;second, patterns of economic geography play a critical role in regional differences of eco-compensation;third, regional cultural and institutional environment affects the formation and implementation of eco-compensation policies and measures;and fourth, geographical methods provide techniques for formulating eco-compensation. The paper suggests that region is a key to studying eco-compensation issues, regional structure is a major reference for formulating eco-compensation policies, externality is the scientific basis to carry out eco-compensation, and ownership of geographical elements and resources is a key factor to distinguish different stakeholders in eco-compensation. As such, eco-compensation studies should take a geographical research paradigm of "region-differentiation-scale". In short, the geographical features of eco-compensation can be best manifested by such terms as regionalization, spatial differentiation, comprehensiveness, and dynamics.

Key words: eco-compensation, geography, features, implications, human-land territorial system

刘春腊, 刘卫东, 陆大道. 生态补偿的地理学特征及内涵研究[J]. 地理研究, 2014, 33(5): 803-816.

LIU Chunla, LIU Weidong, LU Dadao. A study of the geographical features and implications of eco-compensation[J]. GEOGRAPHICAL RESEARCH, 2014, 33(5): 803-816.

参考文献

[1] 吴传钧. 论地理学的研究核心: 人地关系地域系统. 经济地理, 1991, 11(3): 1-6.[Wu Chuanjun. Study on geographic key: Man-earth relationship areal system. Economic Geography, 1991, 11(3): 1-6.]
[2] 郑度, 陈述彭. 地理学研究进展与前沿领域. 地球科学进展, 2001, 16(5): 599-606.[Zheng Du, Chen Shupeng. Progress and disciplinary frontiers of geographical research. Advance In Earth Sciences, 2001, 16(5): 599-606.]
[3] 陆大道. 中国地理学发展若干值得思考的问题. 地理学报, 2003, 58(1): 3-8.[Lu Dadao. Some key issues concerning development of geographical science in China. Acta Geographica Sinica, 2003, 58(1): 3-8.]
[4] (英) 约翰斯顿. 唐晓峰, 等译. 地理学与地理学家. 北京: 商务印书馆, 2010.[Joe Johnston. Tang Xiaofeng et al. trans. Geography and Geographer. Beijing: The Commercial Press, 2010.]
[5] 谢剑斌. 持续林业的分类经营与生态补偿. 北京: 中国环境科学出版社, 2004.[Xie Jianbin. Classified Management and E-compensation of Sustainable Forestry. Beijing: China Environmental Science Press, 2004.]
[6] 吴绍洪, 杨勤业, 郑度. 生态地理区域系统的比较研究. 地理学报, 2003, 58(5): 686-694.[Wu Shaohong, Yang Qinye, Zheng Du. Comparative study on eco-geographic regional systems between China and USA. Acta Geographica Sinica, 2003, 58(5): 686-694.]
[7] 何承耕. 多时空尺度视野下的生态补偿理论与应用研究[D]. 福州: 福建师范大学, 2007.[He Chenggeng. Theory and application of ecological compensation: A multiple temporal-spatial scales perspective[D]. Fuzhou: Fujian Normal University, 2007.]
[8] 胡仪元. 区域经济发展的生态补偿模式研究. 社会科学辑刊, 2007, (4): 123-127.[Hu Yiyuan. Research on ecocompensation model in regional economic development. Social Science Journal, 2007, (4): 123-127.]
[9] 张金泉. 生态补偿机制与区域协调发展. 兰州大学学报(社会科学版), 2007, 35(3): 115-119.[Zhang Jinquan. Ecological supplementary mechanism and the coordinated regional development. Journal of Lanzhou University(Social Sciences), 2007, 35(3): 115-119.]
[10] 吴晓青, 洪尚群, 段昌群, 等. 区际生态补偿机制是区域间协调发展的关键. 长江流域资源与环境, 2003, 12(1): 13-16.[Wu Xiaoqing, Hong Shangqun, Duan Changqun et al. Inter-regional ecological compensation system and regional co-ordinative development. Resources and Environment in the Yangtze Basin, 2003, 12(1): 13-16.]
[11] 傅伯杰, 赵文武, 陈利顶. 地理—生态过程研究的进展与展望. 地理学报, 2006, 61(11): 1123-1131.[Fu Bojie, Zhao Wenwu, Chen Liding. Progress and perspective of geographical-ecological processes. Acta Geographica Sinica, 2006, 61(11): 1123-1131.]
[12] 宋长青, 冷疏影. 当代地理学特征、发展趋势及中国地理学研究进展. 地球科学进展, 2005, 24(6): 595-599.[Song Changqing, Leng Shuying. Characteristics and trend of modern geography and progresses of geographical research in China. Advance in Earth Sciences, 2005, 24(6): 595-599.]
[13] 王金南, 万军, 张惠远. 关于我国生态补偿机制与政策的几点认识. 环境保护, 2006, (19): 24-28.[Wang Jinnan, Wann Jun, Zhang Huiyuan. Cognitions of China's eco-compensation mechanism and policy. Environmental Protection, 2006, (19): 24-28.]
[14] 杨光梅, 闵庆文, 李文华, 等. 我国生态补偿研究中的科学问题. 生态学报, 2007, 27(10): 4289-4300.[Yang Guangmei, Min Qingwen, Li Wenhua, et al. Scientific issues of ecological compensation research in China. Acta Ecologica Sinica, 2007, 27(10): 4289-4300.]
[15] 刘琴. 用生态补偿机制协调区域发展. 中国绿色时报, 2007-08-02(A01).[Liu Qin. Apply ecological compensation mechanism to harmonize regional development. China Green Times, 2007-08-02(A01).]
[16] 王昱. 区域生态补偿的基础理论与实践问题研究[D]. 长春: 东北师范大学, 2009.[Wang Yu. The exploring in fundamental theories and practical issues of regional ecological compensation[D]. Changchun: Northeast Normal University, 2009.]
[17] 胡文蔚, 杜欢政, 李斌. 区域间生态补偿机制推进区域经济协调发展. 嘉兴学院学报, 2007, (1): 5-7, 57.[Hu Wenwei, Du Huanzheng, Li Bing. Setting up interregional ecological compensation mechanism to advance coordinated development of regional economy. Journal of Jiaxing University, 2007, (1): 5-7, 57.]
[18] 王昱, 丁四保, 王荣成. 主体功能区划及其生态补偿机制的地理学依据. 地域研究与开发, 2009, 28(1): 17-21.[Wang Yu, Ding Sibao, Wang Rongcheng. Research on basic geographic theories of major function oriented zone and its mechanism of eco-compensation, Areal Research and Development, 2009, 28(1): 17-21.]
[19] Hong S Q, Ma P J, Guo H G. An exploration of ecological compensation system. Environmental Science and Technology, 2001, (5): 40-43.
[20] 李文华, 刘某承. 关于中国生态补偿机制建设的几点思考. 资源科学, 2010, 32(5): 791-796.[Li Wenhua, Liu Moucheng. Several strategic thoughts on China's eco-compensation mechanism. Resources Science, 2010, 32(5): 791-796.]
[21] 毛显强, 钟瑜, 张胜. 生态补偿的理论探讨. 中国人口. 资源与环境, 2002, 12(4): 40-43.[Mao Xianqiang, Zhong Yu, Zhang Sheng. Conception, theory and mechanism of eco-compensation. China Population, Resources and Environment, 2002, 12(4): 40-43.]
[22] Kumar P, Muradian R. Payment for Ecosystem Services. New Delhi/New York: Oxford University Press, 2009.
[23] Redford K H, Adams W M. Payment for ecosystem services and the challenge of saving nature. Conservation Biology, 2009, 23(4): 785-787.
[24] Gómez-Baggethun E, De Groot R, Lomas P L, et al. The history of ecosystem services in economic theory and practice: from early notions to markets and payment schemes. Ecological Economics, 2010, 69(6): 1209-1218.
[25] 陆大道. 关于地理学的“人-地系统”理论研究. 地理研究, 2002, 21(2): 135-145.[Lu Dadao. Theoretical studies of man-land system as the core of geographical science, Geographical Research, 2002, 21(2): 135-145.]
[26] Shelley B G. What should we call instruments commonly known as payments for environmental services? A review of the literature and a proposal. Annals of the New York Academy of Sciences, 2011, 1219(1): 209-225.
[27] Farley J, Costanza R. Payments for ecosystem services: From local to global. Ecological Economics, 2010, 69(11): 2060-2068.
[28] Vatn A. An institutional analysis of payments for environmental services. Ecological Economics, 2010, 69(6): 1245-1252.
[29] 孙新章, 谢高地, 张其仔, 等. 中国生态补偿的实践及其政策取向. 资源科学, 2006, 28(4): 25-30.[Sun Xinzhang, Xie Gaodi, Zhang Qizi et al. Ecological compensation practice and policy orientation in China. Resources Science, 2006, 28(4): 25-30.]
[30] Pascual U, Muradian R, Rodríguez L C et al. Exploring the links between equity and efficiency in payments for environmental services: A conceptual approach. Ecological Economics, 2010, 69(6): 1237-1244.
[31] Jack B K, Kousky C, Sims K R E. Designing payments for ecosystem services: Lessons from previous experience with incentive-based mechanisms. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences, 2008, 105(28): 9465-9470.
[32] 任勇, 冯东方, 等. 中国生态补偿理论与政策框架设计. 北京: 中国环境科学出版社, 2008.[Ren Yong, Feng Dongfang, et al. Theory and Policy Framework Design of Eco-compensation in China. Beijing: China Environmental Science Press, 2008.]
[33] 中国生态补偿机制与政策研究课题组. 中国生态补偿机制与政策研究. 北京: 科学出版社, 2007.[Task Force on Ecocompensation Mechanisms and Policies, CCICED. Eco-compensation Mechanisms and Policies in China. Beijing: Science Press, 2007.]
[34] Wunder S, Engel S, Pagiola S. Taking stock: A comparative analysis of payments for environmental services programs in developed and developing countries. Ecological Economics, 2008, 65(4): 834-852.
[35] 秦艳红, 康慕谊. 国内外生态补偿现状及其完善措施. 自然资源学报, 2007, 22(4): 557-567.[Qin Yanhong, Kang Muyi. A review of ecological compensation and its improvement measures. Journal of Natural Resources, 2007, 22(4): 557-567.]
[36] Kosoy N, Mutinez-Tuna M, Muradian R et al. Payments for environmental service in watersheds: Insights from a comparative study of two cases in Central America. Ecological Economics, 2007, 61(2): 446-455.
[37] 张伟, 张宏业, 张义丰. 基于“地理要素禀赋当量”的社会生态补偿标准测算. 地理学报, 2010, 65(10): 1253-1265.[Zhang Wei, Zhang Hongye, Zhang Yifeng. The determination of social ecological compensation standard based on "equivalent value of geographical factor endowment". Acta Geographica Sinica, 2010, 65(10): 1253-1265.]
[38] [英]尼尔. 寇,[加]菲利普. 凯利,[新加坡]杨伟聪. 刘卫东, 马丽, 张晓平, 等译. 当代经济地理学导论. 北京: 商务印书馆, 2012.[Nei M Coe, Philip F Kelly, Henry W C Yeung. Liu Weidong, Ma Li, Zhang Xiaoping, et al. trans. Economic Geography: A Contemporary Introduction. Beijing: The Commercial Press, 2012.]
[39] 李平星, 孙威. 经济地理学角度的区域生态补偿机制研究. 生态环境学报, 2010, 19(6): 1507-1512.[Li Pingxing, Sun Wei. Theoretical reflection on ecological compensation from the perspective of economic geography. Ecology and Environmental Sciences, 2010, 19(6): 1507-1512.]
[40] 赵雪雁, 张丽, 江进德, 等. 生态补偿对农户生计的影响: 以甘南黄河水源补给区为例. 地理研究, 2013, 32(3): 531-542.[Zhao Xueyan, Zhang Li, Jiang Jinde, et al. The impact of ecological compensation:A case study of Huanghe River Water on the farmers" livelihood Supply Areas of Gannan. Geographical Research, 2013, 32(3): 531-542.]
[41] 侯成成, 赵雪雁, 张丽, 等. 生态补偿对区域发展影响研究的进展. 中国农学通报, 2011, 27(11): 104-107.[Hou Chengcheng, Zhao Xueyan, Zhang Li et al. Advances on the impacts of ecological compensation to regional development. Chinese Agricultural Science Bulletin, 2011, 27(11): 104-107.]
[42] 李双成, 蔡运龙. 地理尺度转换若干问题的初步探讨. 地理研究, 2005, 24(1): 11-18.[Li Shuangcheng, Cai Yunlong. Some scaling issues of geography. Geographical Research, 2005,24(1):11-18.]
[43] 李小建. 经济地理学研究中的尺度问题. 经济地理, 2005, 25(4): 433-436.[Li Xiaojian. Scale and economic geography inquiry. Economic Geography, 2005, 25(4): 433-436.]
[44] Roland Schulze. Transcending scales of space and time in impact studies of climate and climate change on agrohydrological responses. Agriculture, Ecosystems and Environment, 2001, 82: 185-212.
[45] Lam N, Quattrochi D A. On the issues of scale, resolution, and fractral analysis is in the mapping sciences. Prof. Geogr., 1992, 44: 88-987.
[46] (美)哈特向. 黎樵, 译. 地理学性质的透视. 北京: 商务印书馆, 2009.[Hartshorne R. Li Jiao tran. Perspective of Geography Properties. Beijing: The Commercial Press, 2009.]
[47] 戴其文, 赵雪雁, 徐伟, 等. 生态补偿对象空间选择的研究进展及展望. 自然资源学报, 2009, 24(10): 1772-1784.[Dai Qiwen, Zhao Xueyan, Xu Wei, et al. The research advances and perspectives of spatial selection of ecological compensation objects.Journal of Natural Resources, 2009, 24(10): 1772-1784.]
[48] 戴其文. 生态补偿对象的空间选择研究: 以甘南藏族自治州草地生态系统的水源涵养服务为例. 自然资源学报, 2010, 25(3): 415-425.[Dai Qiwen. Study on the spatial selection of ecological compensation objects: A case study of water conservation of grasslands in Gannan Tibetan Autonomous Prefecture. Journal of Natural Resources, 2010, 25(3): 415-425.]
[49] 顾朝林, 王恩儒, 石爱华. “新经济地理学”与经济地理学的分异与对立. 地理学报, 2002, 57(4): 497-504.[Gu Chaolin, Wang Enru, Shi Aihua. Divarication and opposability between"new economic geography"and economic geography. Acta Geographica Sinica, 2002, 57(4): 497-504.]
[50] 刘卫东, 陆大道. 经济地理学研究进展. 中国科学院院刊, 2004, 19(1): 35-39.[Liu Weidong, Lu Dadao. The development of economic geography in China: Progress and suggestions. Bulletin of the Chinese Academy of Sciences, 2004, 19(1): 35-39.]
[51] 李小建, 苗长虹. 西方经济地理学新进展及其启示. 地理学报, 2004, 59(Suppl.): 153-161.[Li Xiaojian,Miao Changhong. Recent developments in western economic geographies and theoretical thinking for China's counterpart. Acta Geographica Sinica, 2004, 59(Suppl.): 153-161.]
[52] 谭秋成. 关于生态补偿标准和机制. 中国人口.资源与环境, 2009, 19(6): 1-6.[Tan Qiucheng. Eco-compensation standard and mechanism. China Population, Resources and Environment, 2009, 19(6): 1-6.]
[53] Engel Stefanie, Pagiola Stefano, Wunder Sven. Designing payments for environmental services in theory and practice: An overview of the issues. Ecological Economics, 2008, 65: 663-674.
[54] 赵翠薇, 王世杰. 生态补偿效益、标准: 国际经验及对我国的启示. 地理研究, 2010, 29(4): 597-606.[Zhao Cuiwei, Wang Shijie. Benefits and standards of ecological compensation: International experiences and revelations for China Geographical Research, 2010, 29(4): 597-606.]
[55] Wünscher T, Engel S, Wunder S. Spatial targeting of payments for environmental services: A tool for boosting conservation benefits. Ecological Economics, 2008, 65(4): 822-833.
[56] 宋晓谕, 徐中民, 祁元, 等. 青海湖流域生态补偿空间选择与补偿标准研究. 冰川冻土, 2013, 35(2): 496-503.[Song Xiaoyu, Xu Zhongmin, Qi Yuan, et al. Study on spatial target and compensation standard of eco-compensation in Qinghai Lake watershed. Journal of Glaciology and Geocryology, 2013, 35(2): 496-503.]
[57] Herzog F, Dreier S, Hofer G, et al. Effect of ecological compensation areas on floristic and breeding bird diversity in Swiss agricultural landscapes. Agriculture, Ecosystems and Environment, 2005, 108: 189-204.
[58] 刘益军, 张素强, 王小屈, 等. 3S 技术在自然保护区生态补偿管理中的应用. 北京林业大学学报, 2011, 33(Suppl.2): 16-22.[Liu Yijun, Zhang Suqiang, Wang Xiaoqu, et al. Application of RS, GPS and GIS technologies in ecocompensation management of nature reserves. Journal of Beijing Forestry University, 2011, 33(Suppl.2): 16-22.]
[59] 高瑞. 基于GIS 的生态补偿空间均衡性分析[D]. 武汉: 华中师范大学, 2007.[Gao Rui. An analysis on spatial balanced and ecological compensation using GIS. Wu Han: Central China Normal University, 2007.]
[60] 赵雪雁, 董霞. 最小数据方法在生态补偿中的应用: 以甘南黄河水源补给区为例. 地理科学, 2010, 30(5): 748-754.[Zhao Xueyan, Dong Xia. Application of minimum-data approach in ecological compensation: A case of Huanghe River water supply area of Gannan. Scientia Geographica Sinica, 2010, 30(5): 748-754.]
[61] 熊鹰, 王克林, 蓝万炼, 等. 洞庭湖区湿地恢复的生态补偿效应评估. 地理学报, 2004, 59(5): 772-780.[Xiong Ying, Wang Kelin, Lan Wanlian, et al. Evaluation of the lake recovery area eco-compensation in Dongting Lake Wetland. Acta Geographica Sinica, 2004, 59(5): 772-780.]
[62] 陆大道, 樊杰, 刘卫东, 等. 中国地域空间、功能及其发展. 北京: 中国大地出版社, 2011: 58-101.[Lu Dadao, Fan Jie, Liu Weidong, et al. Geographical space, Function and Development in China. Beijing: China Land Press, 2011.]
[63] 俞海, 任勇. 流域生态补偿机制的关键问题分析: 以南水北调中线水源涵养区为例. 资源科学, 2007, 29(2): 28-33.[Yu Hai, Ren Yong. Key issues of watershed eco-compensation mechanism: A case study in water source areas of South-to-North Water Transfer. Resources Science, 2007, 29(2): 28-33.]
[64] 丁四保, 王晓云. 我国区域生态补偿的基础理论与体制机制问题探讨. 东北师大学报(哲学社会科学版), 2008, (4): 5-10.[Ding Sibao, Wang Xiaoyun. Theory and mechanism of the regional eco-environmental compensation. Journal of Northeast Normal University (Philosophy and Social Sciences), 2008, (4): 5-10.]
[65] Sánchez-Azofeifa G A, Pfaff A, Robalino J A, et al. Costa Rica's payment for environmental services program: intention, implementation, and impact. Conservation Biology, 2007, 21(5): 1165-1173.
[66] Wunder S, Albán M. Decentralized payments for environmental services: The cases of Pimampiro and PROFAFOR in Ecuador. Ecological Economics, 2008, 65(4): 685-698.
[67] Muradian R, Corbera E, Pascual U, et al. Reconciling theory and practice: An alternative conceptual framework for understanding payments for environmental services. Ecological Economics, 2010, 69(6): 1202-1208.
[68] Bishop J, Pagiola S. Selling Forest Environmental Services: Market-based Mechanisms for Conservation and Development. Routledge, 2012.
[69] 万本太, 邹首民. 走向实践的生态补偿: 案例分析与探索. 北京: 中国环境科学出版社, 2008.[Wang Bentai, Zou Shoumin. Practical of Eco-compensation: Cases Analysis and Exploration. Beijing: China Environmental Science Press, 2008.]
[70] Wunder S. Payments for Environmental Services: Some Nuts and Bolts. Jakarta: CIFOR, 2005.
[71] Muradian R, Corbera E, Pascual U et al. Reconciling theory and practice: An alternative conceptual framework for understanding payments for environmental services. Ecological Economics, 2010, 69(6): 1202-1208.
[72] Kroeger T, Casey F. An assessment of market-based approaches to providing ecosystem services on agricultural lands. Ecological Economics, 2007, 64(2): 321-332.
[73] Angelsen A. REDD models and baselines. International Forestry Review, 2008, 10(3): 465-475.
[74] Sepp C, Mansur E. National forest programmes: A comprehensive framework for participatory planning. UNASYLVAFAO-, 2006, 57(3): 6.
[75] Wunder S. The efficiency of payments for environmental services in tropical conservation. Conservation Biology, 2007, 21(1): 48-58.