从美丽乡村到都市居民消费空间——行动者网络理论与大世凹村的社会空间重构
作者简介:陈培培(1989- ),女,河南焦作人,硕士,主要从事城市与区域规划、消费空间研究。E-mail: 18205176076@163.com
收稿日期: 2014-12-27
要求修回日期: 2015-04-24
网络出版日期: 2015-08-20
基金资助
国家自然科学基金项目(41371150)
From beautiful village to urban residents' consumption space: Actor-network theory and the social space reconstruction of Dashiao village
Received date: 2014-12-27
Request revised date: 2015-04-24
Online published: 2015-08-20
Copyright
大都市近郊美丽乡村的建设为城市居民假日消费提供了新的场所,成为一种新型都市居民消费空间。运用行动者网络理论,对南京市江宁区“世凹桃源”大世凹美丽乡村的重构过程与机制进行分析。指出美丽乡村建设的背后是一个以地方政府为关键行动者的异质行动者网络,主要实现了乡村物质生活空间的改变。随着政府目标意图的转变,鼓励政策退出及市场机制进入,行动者网络重新调整,消费者和外来经营者成为关键行动者,相应地呈现从美丽乡村到都市居民消费空间的转变,即进一步实现社会空间的重构。由于行动者网络是一个充满利益争夺和协商的动态连接,社会空间的重构也是一个持续的过程。研究表明,美丽乡村不仅是提供村民生活和游客抒情怀旧的场所,而且是一个存在权力关系且动态变化的行动者网络空间。政府、组织、村民、消费者、资本、景观、文化等异质性行动者自身的定义与再定义,以及相互之间的作用构成美丽乡村形成与转变机制。揭示了在乡村建设与转型发展过程中,政府及政策的作用机制及其有效时域,市场机制的灵活性及其所带来的利益争端与社会不公问题。
陈培培 , 张敏 . 从美丽乡村到都市居民消费空间——行动者网络理论与大世凹村的社会空间重构[J]. 地理研究, 2015 , 34(8) : 1435 -1446 . DOI: 10.11821/dlyj201508003
Recently emerging beautiful villages in suburbs provide citizens very places for recreation, and can be considered as a new kind of urban residents' consumption space. From the perspective of actor-network theory, this study analyses the social-spatial reconstruction of Dashiao village. Through the tracing of translation, including four stages of problematization, interessement, enrollment and mobilization, the process and mechanism of the reconstruction of Dashiao beautiful village and the later consumption space was explored. It was manifested in the following four aspects: 1) In the process of the transformation from an usual village to a beautiful village, there was a heterogeneous actor-network, in which Jiangning District government played a focal role mainly by improving the physical environment of the village. 2) Heterogeneous actors changed their roles through urban residents' consumption activities. Along with the quit of incentives launched by government to rural residents, market mechanisms involved, district government and market forces of foreign business and consumers allied to become alternative focal actors, while villagers withdrew to the periphery of the actor network, which contributed to the re-establishment of actor network and the beautiful village's transformation to urban residents' consumption space. In order to meet consumers' demand, everyday lives of villagers' was represented partially to show the imaged rural life, but the real lives of villages was marginalized or hidden. Non-native culture and life style was transplanted or symbolically adopted, while the original village was fading away. 3) This paper explains the mechanism of social-spatial reconstruction of Dashiao village through the two sequential actor networks and how it transformed from the first to second. The transformation of intended target, which should be decided by focal actor of the actor network, the local government, from improving the physical environment to promotion of economic development determined the direction of the reconstruction of social space, as well as outside investment managers, and consumers attended and became key actors. Changes of structure and channel of interests in the actor network lead to the exit, redefinition and entering of actors. The reconstruction of social space is an ongoing process since the actor network is a dynamic connection, fulfilling of interests conflicts and negotiation. 4) From the actor-network perspective, beautiful village was not only a place for villagers' living and the tourists' poetic nostalgia, but also a networked space which is weaved of complex and dynamic relations of power. This paper points out the effectiveness and the time limitation of government and policy mechanisms, and the flexibility of the market mechanism, which brings about interest conflicts and social injustice. In the case of Dashiao, local residents withdrew from the masters of the village to marginalized role of urban residents' consumption space, and they have never played key actors during the establishment of the above two actor-networks.
Key words: beautiful village; consumption space; actor-network theory; social space
Fig. 1 The location of Dashiao village in Nanjing图1 大世凹村在南京的区位图 |
Fig. 2 A research framework of Dashiao social space reconstruction with ANT perspective图2 ANT视角下的大世凹村社会空间重构的理论框架 |
Fig. 3 Actors and OPP of beautiful village construction图3 美丽乡村建设的行动者与强制通行点 |
Fig. 4 The actor network of beautiful village construction图4 美丽乡村建设的行动者网络 |
Tab. 1 Comparations of basic situation between beautiful village and urban residents' consumption space表1 美丽乡村与都市居民消费空间的基本情况对比 |
| 美丽乡村 | 都市居民消费空间 | ||
|---|---|---|---|
| 居民构成 | 36户本地 | 24户本地+24户外来 | |
| 村庄土地利用 结构 | 26%居住用地,13%耕地,49%林地,8%水体,4%其他 | 21%商住用地,6%公共服务设施用地,13%休闲娱乐用地,49%林地,8%水体,3%其他 | |
| 村民收入结构 | 外出打工+农业 | 个体经营+外出打工+租赁 | |
| 非农经济活动概况 | 个体经营户 | 1家小商店 | 初期23家,其中包括19户农家乐饭店,2家茶社,1家农产品超市和1家旅社。 |
| 户均接待规模 | 无 | 120人/天 | |
| 旺季游客量 | 较少 | 2000人/天 | |
| 平均月收入 | 2000元/月/人 | 1万元/月/户(个体经营户),2000元/月/人(非经营户) | |
| 形象特征 | 整洁、优美,富有徽派特色的乡村聚落 | 乡村基底叠加消费景观 | |
Fig. 5 The translation of actors by urban residents’ consumption activities图5 都市居民消费活动对行动者的转译 |
Fig. 6 The space distribution of dealers in Dashiao village图6 大世凹村本地及外来经营户空间分布情况 |
The authors have declared that no competing interests exist.
| [1] |
|
| [2] |
|
| [3] |
|
| [4] |
|
| [5] |
|
| [6] |
|
| [7] |
|
| [8] |
|
| [9] |
|
| [10] |
|
| [11] |
|
| [12] |
|
| [13] |
|
| [14] |
|
| [15] |
|
| [16] |
[
|
| [17] |
[
|
| [18] |
[
|
| [19] |
[
|
| [20] |
|
| [21] |
[
|
| [22] |
|
| [23] |
[
|
| [24] |
[
|
| [25] |
[
|
| [26] |
[
|
| [27] |
|
/
| 〈 |
|
〉 |