城市CBD功能成熟度评价指标体系的构建——以杭州钱江新城CBD为例
收稿日期: 2007-08-22
修回日期: 2008-01-24
网络出版日期: 2008-05-25
基金资助
国家社科基金资助项目(05CJY017)
The construction of the CBD functional maturity index system:A case of Qianjiang New City CBD
Received date: 2007-08-22
Revised date: 2008-01-24
Online published: 2008-05-25
Supported by
国家社科基金资助项目(05CJY017)
本文基于"如何衡量CBD的功能发育程度"这一极具现实意义的问题,通过以杭州钱江新城CBD为例,结合国内外CBD研究中的理论及实践经验,采用德尔菲法归纳出总体规模、功能协调、功能集聚和功能辐射四大类指标,并进一步从可操作性的角度进行了细分,最终形成1项目标层(A层)、4项准则层(B层)和18项基础指标层(C层)的一整套较为完善的CBD功能成熟度指标体系。文中采用层次分析法,通过对32位相关专家学者的问卷调查,确定了各项基础指标的权重,并通过了一致性检验。结果表明,就准则层指标而言,显然CBD的功能集聚程度B3(0.4085)和功能辐射程度B4(0.3392),更能凸显CBD作为城市区域经济的核心地位。而且,各基础指标层内部也存在着显著的差异。
贾生华, 聂 冲, 温海珍 . 城市CBD功能成熟度评价指标体系的构建——以杭州钱江新城CBD为例[J]. 地理研究, 2008 , 27(3) : 649 -658 . DOI: 10.11821/yj2008030018
This paper was based on the practically significant problem,how to weigh the development degree of function in CBD. Based on the case of Qianjiang New City CBD, we constructed a whole functional maturity index system which included 4 subgroups, namely collective scale, harmony function, agglomeration function and radiation function. From the perspective of feasibility, we subdivided those 4 subgroups into 18 indices. Using the AHP(Analytical Hierarchy Process), we acquired weight of each basic index, and the indices judgement matrix also passed through the consistency test. As to the criterion level indices, we found the degree of agglomeration function and radiation function of CBD is dominant in the regional economy. Then, in the index level, we found that the economic scale is more important than the scale of construction and the population; and that office building is still the core part of CBD, but the retail/service and housing are also important; next, the cluster of the corporate headquarters and the financial industry is the main characters of the agglomerative function of CBD; and the last but not least, under the background of economic globalization, the radiation function put more emphasis on the economic relationship between the international/regional economic body and CBD than on others. And also, the paper aims to do some help to the practical and theoretical society.
[1] Harris C D, Ulman E. The nature of cities. American Academy of Political and Social Science, 1945, 242: 7~17.
[2] Murphy R E, Vance J E, Epstein B T. Internal structure of the CBD. Economic Geography, 1955, 31(1): 21~46.
[3] Scott P.The Australian CBD. Economic Geography, 1959, 35(3): 290~314.
[4] Herbert D T, Thomas C J.Urban Geography: A First Approach. London: John Villey and Sons, 1982. 200~216.
[5] Davies D H.Zambia in maps: Graphic perspectives of a developing country. New York: Africana Pub. Corp. , 1972.
[6] Friedman J J.Variations in the level of central business district retail activity among large U.S. cities: 1954 and 1967.Land Economics, 1973, 49(3): 326~335.
[7] Brooks J S, Young A H. Revitalising the central business district in the face of decline: The case of New Orleans, 1973~1993. Town Planning Review. ,1993, 64(3): 251~271.
[8] Nakamura R. Ofisu-Biru Chintai-ry no Hedonikku Bunseki (An hedonic analysis of the rent of office building), Okayama Daigaku Keizai Gakkai Zasshi.(Journal of Economic Society of Okayama University), 1994, 25: 239~256.
[9] Webb R B, Fisher J D. Development of an effective rent (Lease) index for the Chicago CBD. Journal of Urban Economics, 1996, 39: 1~19.
[10] Nagai K, Kondo Y, Ohta M. An hedonic analysis of the rental office market in the Tokyo central business district: 1985-1994 Fiscal Years. The Japanese Economic Review, 2000, 52(1): 130~154.
[11] Alperovich G, Deutsch J. Joint estimation of population density functions and the location of the central business district. Journal of Urban Economics, 1994, 36(3): 239~248.
[12] O’Hara D J. Location of firms within a square central business district. Journal of Political Economy, 1977, 85(6): 1189~1207.
[13] Atack J, Margo R A.Location, Location, Location! The price gradient for vacant urban land: New York, 1835 to 1900. Journal of Real Estate Finance and Economics, 1998, 16(2): 151~162.
[14] Colwell, P F, Munneke H J.Land prices and land assembly in the CBD. The Journal of Real Estate Finance and Economics, 1999, 18(2): 163~180.
[15] Voith R. Parking, transit, and employment in a central business district. Journal of Urban Economics, 1998, 44: 43~58.
[16] Hensher D A, King J. Parking demand and responsiveness to supply, pricing and location in the Sydney Central Business District. Transportation Research Part A, 2001, 35: 177~196.
[17] Goudie D. Zonal method for urban travel surveys: Sustainability and sample distance from the CBD. Journal of Transport Geography, 2002, 10: 287~301.
[18] McMillen D P, McDonald J F.Suburban subcenters and employment density in metropolitan Chicago. Journal of Urban Economics, 1998, 43: 157~180.
[19] 周岚. 论CBD的合理规模. 城市研究, 1994,(5): 19~21.
[20] 汤建中. 上海CBD的演化和职能调整. 城市规划, 1995,(3): 35~38.
[21] 樊绯. 20世纪城市发展与CBD功能的演变. 城市发展研究, 2000,(4): 43~46.
[22] 孟凌. 重庆市CBD演化过程及其机制研究. 四川师范学院学报(哲学社会科学版), 2000,(7): 41~44.
[23] 阎小培, 周春山, 冷勇, 等. 广州CBD的功能特征与空间结构.地理学报, 2000, 55(4): 475~486.
[24] 查德利, 贺红权, 吴江. 城市中心区演化与中心商务区形成机理. 重庆大学学报, 2003, 26(3): 110~113.
[25] 郑伯红, 陈瑛. 重庆大都市区CBD系统演变的机制与规律. 经济地理, 2004, 24(1): 48~52.
[26] 王绪伟. 北京商务中心规划初步探讨. 城市规划, 1993,(4): 35~38.
[27] 陈联. CBD规划研究的前提及方法. 城市规划, 1995,(3): 32~34.
[28] 高波, 钱蓁. 中等城市向百万级人口大城市扩容中的CBD规划与建设——以扬州来鹤台广场开发建设为案例的分析. 南京社会科学, 2003,(5): 22~29.
[29] 杨俊宴, 吴明伟. 中国城市CBD适建度指标体系研究——中国CBD发展量化研究之一. 城市规划, 2006, 30(1): 13~19.
[30] 杨俊宴, 吴明伟. 城市CBD与产业规模结构量化比较——中国CBD发展量化研究之三. 城市规划, 2006, 30(3): 13~19.
[31] 王德忠, 庄仁兴. 区域经济联系定量分析初探——以上海与无锡常州地区经济联系为例. 地理科学, 1996, 16(1):51~57.
[32] 牛慧恩, 孟庆民, 胡其昌, 陈延诚. 甘肃榆毗邻省区区域经济联系研究. 经济地理, 1998, 18(3):51~56.
[33] 李国平, 王立明, 杨开忠. 深圳与珠江三角洲区域经济联系的测度及分析. 经济地理, 2001, 21(1): 33~37.
[34] 郑国, 赵群毅. 山东半岛城市群主要经济联系方向研究. 地域研究与开发, 2004, 23(5):51~54.
[35] 苗长虹, 王海江. 河南省城市的经济联系方向与强度——兼论中原城市群的形成与对外联系. 地理研究, 2006, 25(2):222~232.
[36] 刘承良, 余瑞林, 熊剑平, 等. 武汉都市圈经济联系的空间结构. 地理研究, 2007, 26(1): 197~209.
[37] Eeturck D M.The approach to consistency in the Analytic Hierarchy Process. Modelling, 1987(9): 61~65.
[38] Saaty T L. The Analytic Hierechy Process. New York: Hill, 1980.
/
| 〈 |
|
〉 |