对气候变暖问题争议的分析
收稿日期: 2000-12-22
修回日期: 2001-02-28
网络出版日期: 2001-04-15
基金资助
“国家重点基础研究发展规划”项目(G1998040900);自然科学基金项目(49635190)资助
On debates concerning the global warming
Received date: 2000-12-22
Revised date: 2001-02-28
Online published: 2001-04-15
综合评述和分析了近年来关于全球气候变暖问题的研究。重点是有关气候变暖的一些争议。目前的结论是:(1)19世纪中期以来全球平均地表气温上升了0.4～0.8℃;(2)全球气候变暖的论断得到了海洋温度、大气温度、钻孔温度、陆地雪盖、海冰及冰川资料的支持;(3)1998年是近一个半世纪有观测资料以来最暖的一年,对1961～1990年平均的距平为0.55℃。20世纪变暖的趋势为0.066℃/10a;(4)1990′s是20世纪最暖的10年,平均气温距平0.35℃,也可能是500a或者甚至1000a来最暖的10年。所以,20世纪气候的变暖是无可怀疑的。人类活动影响很可能是20世纪气候变暖的主要原因,至少是主要原因之一。
王绍武, 龚道溢 . 对气候变暖问题争议的分析[J]. 地理研究, 2001 , 20(2) : 153 -160 . DOI: 10.11821/yj2001020004
Some problems in the global climate studies are discussed in this manuscript Special attention was given to the debates on global warming Although it is widely accepted that the anthropologic greenhouse effect would be responsible for the recent global warming, there are always unceasing skepticism Numerous evidences show that it is indubitable on the climate warming itself The global surface air temperature has increased by 0.4-0.8℃ since the mid 19th century Substantial changes associated with the climatic warming also occurred during the past century These related transformations have been observed in the ocean temperature, atmospheric temperature, reconstructed temperatures from the evaluation of mountain snowlines and borehole thermometry, land snow cover, sea ice cover and the mountanious glaciers It is found that 1998 is the warmest year on records during the past 150 years Global averaged annual temperature in 1998 is 0.55℃ above the mean of 1961-1990 The linear warming trend for the 20th century is 0.066℃ /10a The 1990s (with the anomaly of +0.35℃ ) is the warmest decade not only in the 20th century but also in the past 500 years and maybe even in the last millennium After all, the global warming in the 20th century is an explicit fact, whereas there are doubts on which factor should be responsible for it Anthropologic factor may be the most important reason, at least, may be one of the most important factors if there are some other crucial causes To some degree, the sciences of climate change benefit from the debates on the global warming , since there are increasing concerns and demands for a better understanding of the climate system (including their natural variability and their interaction with the human induced greenhouse effects) Unfortunately, the debates and some related conclusions are no more “pure” scientific questions, but political affairs.
Key words： global warming; debates
[1] Houghton J T,Filho L GM,Callander B A,et al,(Eds). Climate Change 1995:The Science of Climate Change
[C]1Cambridge University Press,Cambridge,U K,19961572.
[2] Singer S F. Human contribution on climate change remains questionable
[J].EOS,1999,80(16).
[3] Easterling D R,Horton B,Jones P D,et al1 Maximum and minimum temperature trends for t he globe
[J]. Science,1997,277:364367.
[4] Peterson T C,Easterling D R,Karl T R,et al. Homogeneity adjust ments of in situ at mospheric climate data:a review
[J]. Int J Climatol,1998,18:14951517.
[5] Peterson T C,Gallo K P,Livermore J,et al. Global rural temperature trends
[J]. Geophys Res Lett,1999,26:3292332.
[6] Jones P D,New M,Parker D E. Surface air temperature and its changes over t he past 150 years
[J].Rev in Geophyics,1999,37:173199.
[7] Karl T R,Knight R W and Baker B. The record breaking global temperatures of 1997 and 1998:evidence for an increasein t he rate of global warming
[J]. Geophys Res Lett,2000,27:719722.
[8] Folland C K and Parker D E1 Correlation of instrumental biases in historical sea surface temperature data
[J].Q J R MetSoc,1995,121:319367.
[9] Folland C K,Rayner N,Frich P,et al. Uncertainties in climate data set-a challenge for WMO
[J]. WMO Bull,2000,49:5968.
[10] Shen S S,Smit h T M,Ropelewski C F,et al. An optimal regional averaging met hod wit h error estimates and a test using tropical Pacific SST data
[J].J Climate,1998,11:23402350.
[11] Diggle P J,Liang K-Y and Zeger S L.Analysis of longitudinal data
[M].Oxford,Clarendon Press,1999.253.
[12] Levitus S,Antonov J,Boyer T P et al. Warming of t he world ocean
[J].Science,2000,287(5461):22252229.
[13] White W B,Cayan D R,and Lean J. Global upper ocean heat storage response to radiative forcing from changing solar irradanceand increasing greenhouse gas/aerosol concentrations
[J].J Geophys. Res,1998,103:2135521366.
[14] Gaffen D J,Sargent M A,Habermann R E,et al1 Sensitivity of tropospheric and stratospheric temperature trends toradiosonde data quality
[J].J Climate,2000,13(10):17761796.
[15] Brown S J,Parker D E and Folland C K. Comparison of MSU-R wit h observed tropospheric and surface temperaturetrends
[J].Geophys Res Lett,2000,27(7):9971000.
[16] Chanin M-L and Ramaswamy V. Trends in stratospheric temperatures. In Scientific Assessment of Ozone Depletion 1998,Global Ozone Research and Monitoring Project
[R].WMO Report No. 44.Geneva:1999,5115159.
[17] Huang S,Pollack H N and Shen P Y. Late Quaternary temperature changes seen in world-wide continental heat flowmeasurements
[J].Geophys Res Lett,1997,24:19471950
[18] Pollack H,Huang S and Shen P Y. Climate change revealed by subsurface temperatures:A global perspective
[J].Science,1998,282:279281.
[19] Robinson D A. Nort hern Hemisphere snow cover during t he satellite era
[C].In Proceedings of 5t h Conference of PolarMeteorology and Ocean. Dallas,TX,AMS,Boston,M A,1999:255260.
[20] Hughes M G and Robinson D A1 Historical snow cover variability in t he Great Plains region of t he USA:1910 t hrough to1993
[J]. Int J Climatology,1996,16:10051018.
[21] Parkinson C L,Cavalieri D J,Gloersen P,et al.Arctic sea ice extents,areas,and trends,1978-1996
[J].J GeophysRes,1999,104(C9):2083720856.
[22] Vinnikov K Y,Robock A,Stouffer R J,et al. Global warming and Northern Hemisphere sea ice extent
[J].Science,1999,286:19341937.
[23] Cavalieri D J,Gloersen P,Parkinson C L,et al. Observed hemispheric asymmetry in global sea ice changes
[J].Science,1997,278:11041106.
[24] Haeberli W,Hoelzle H and Suter S(Eds.). Into t he second century of worldwide glacier monitoring:prospects andstrategies,A contribution to t he International Hydrolgical Programme(IHP)and t he Global Environment MonitoringSystem(GEMS)
[R]1UN ESCO Studies and Reports in Hydrology,56,Paris,1998.
[25] Oerlemans J,Anderson B,Hubbard A1 Modelling t he response of glaciers to climate warming
[J]. Climate Dynamics,1998,14:267274.
[26] Diaz H F and Graham H F1 Recent changes in tropical freezing heights and role of sea surface temperatnre
[J]1Nature,1996,383:152155.
[27] Magnuson J J,Robertson D M,Benson B J,et al. Historical trends in lake and river ice cover in t he nort hern hemisphere
[J].Science,2000,289:174317461
[28] Bradley R S and Jones P D.‘Little Ice Age(summer temperature variations:t heir nature and relevance to recent globalwarming trends
[J].Holocene,1993,3,367376.
[29] Mann M E,Park J and Bradley R S. Global interdecadal and century-scale oscillations during t he past five centuries
[J].Nature,1995,378:266270.
[30] Overpeck J,Hughen K,Hardy D,et al. Arctic environmental change of t he last four centuries
[J].Science,1997,278:12511256.
[31] Jones P D,Briffa K R,Barnett T P,et al. High2resolution palaeoclimatic records for t he last millennium:interpreta2tion,integration and comparison wit h General Circulation Model control run temperatures
[J].Holocene,1998,8:4772483.
[32] Mann M E,Bradley R S and Hughes M K. Nort hern Hemisphere temperatures during t he past millennium:Inferences,uncertainties and limitations
[J].Geophys Res Lett,1999,26:756762.
[33] Alley R B,Clark P U,Keigwin L D,et al. Making sense of millennial-scale climate change. In Mechanisms of GlobalClimate Change at Millennial Time Scales
[J].Geophysical Monograph,1999,112:385394.
[34] Bond G C,Showers W,Elliot M,et al. The Nort h Atlantics 1-2kyr climate rhyt hm:relation to Heinrich events,Dansgaard/Oeschger cycles and t he Little Ice Age.In Mechanisms of Global Climate Change at Millennial Time Scales
[J]1Geophysical Monograph,1999,112:3558.
[35] Beer J,Mende W and Stellmacher R. The role of t he sun in climate forcing1 In Past Global Changes and t heir Signifi2cance for t he Future
[J].Quaternary Science Reviews,2000,19(1-5):403415.
[36] Zielinski G A. Use of paleo2records in determining variability within the volcanism climate system. In Past Global Changes andtheir Significance for the Future
[J].Quaternary Science Reviews,2000,19(1-5):417438.
[37] Linden E. The big meltdown,As t he temperature rises in t he Arctic,it sends a chill around t he planet
[R]. Time,September 4,2000.
[38] Hansen J,Sato M,Ruedy R,et al.Global warming in t he twenty-first century:An alternative scenario
[J].PNAS,2000,97(18):98759880.
/
| 〈 |
|
〉 |