从新文化地理学重构人文地理学的研究框架
收稿日期: 2003-05-11
修回日期: 2003-09-23
网络出版日期: 2004-02-15
基金资助
国家自然科学基金资助项目(40201013)
Re-constructing the research frame of Human Geography from perspectives of New Cultural Geography
Received date: 2003-05-11
Revised date: 2003-09-23
Online published: 2004-02-15
指出TerryG Jordan等人在“Thehumanmosaic”一书中所提出的、并被国内人文地理教科书所采用的分析框架仍然属于传统人文地理学的分析框架 ,偏重于文化生态学和文化景观学派。而deBlij等人在“Humangeography :culture ,society ,andspace”第 6版教科书中所出示的框架图 ,显示出人文地理学研究问题和思路的新变化。新文化地理学的发展使人文地理学研究框架的重构问题突显出来。作者尝试将传统人文地理学和新文化地理学结合 ,利用 5个复数概念 :属性 (attributes)、空间 (spaces)、时间 (times)、方法 (approaches)和世界(worlds) ,构建了ASTAW框架。该概念框架的排列组合关系 ,可用以指导人文地理学问题的建构和研究路径 ,丰富以往人文地理学的内容体系 ,具有相应的时代应用价值。
李蕾蕾 . 从新文化地理学重构人文地理学的研究框架[J]. 地理研究, 2004 , 23(1) : 125 -134 . DOI: 10.11821/yj2004010015
By reviewing the two research frames appearing in the textbooks of Human Geography The Human Mosaic by Terry G. Jordan and Human Geography: Culture, Society, and Space(6 th edition ) by de Blij et al., the author indicates that although the Chinese textbooks of Human Geography have drawn on and accepted the Jordan's frame, this frame still belongs to the traditional human geography which stresses too much on cultural ecology and the Saurian cultural landscape school. However, the frame cited in de Blij's above-mentioned book, which is originally from the National Research Council in US,shows some fresh issues and perspectives in current Human Geography. The development of New Cultural Geography has made it necessary and emergent to construct a new research agenda which can be integrated with both the old and the new human geographies. This article tries to use and redefine five concepts:attributes',spaces',times',approaches' and worlds' to build a research frame, namely ASTAW frame. With this ASTAW frame, the author expects that Human Geography as a discipline will be more systematic and more easily understood by non-geographers. This frame can be also expected to be used in active academic researches esp. on issues in a changing reality. ASTAW frame is essentially based on new cultural geographies' epistemology, approaches and world views. In this frame, the boundary of subjects esp. the boundary between Geography and Human Geography has been understated intentionally. Cultural and social factors influencing the order of nature are emphasized in the frame. The idea of regarding scientific positivism as just one of all human being's wisdom is highlighted in the paper. Therefore, the new research issues in Human Geography as well as Geography will also focus on the representational world rather than just on the real world or physical world which is usually thought of independent on human being and which is traditionally the research core of scientific geography. Spatial study and representational study in new Geography and Human Geography will emphasize the approaches of cultural studies rather than just study the cultural items in traditional and scientific spatial research perspective. The author expects this paper on the new construction of research frame of human geography will attract more attention on the cultural turn of geography and the new cultural geography in China's academic field.
[1] Mitchell D.Cultural Geography:A Critical Introduction.UK:Blackwell Publishers Ltd,2000.xiv.
[2] Goodwin M.Structure2agency.In:Paul Cloke,Philip Crang and Mark Goodwin(eds.),Introducing Human Geographies.Lon2don:Arnold,2002.35～42.
[3] 王恩涌等编著.人文地理学.北京:高等教育出版社,2000.
[4] 陈慧林主编.人文地理学.北京:科学出版社,2001.
[5] 高增伟主编.中国民俗地理.苏州:苏州大学出版社,1999.
[6] 胡兆量,等编著.中国文化地理概述.北京:北京大学出版社,2001.
[7] Jordan T G,Mona Domosh,Lester Rowntree.The Human Mosaic:A Thematic Introduction to Cultural Geography.7 thedition.New York:Longman,1997.3～35.
[8] de Blij Harm J,Alexander B Murphy.Human Geography:Culture,Society and Space.6thedition.New York:John Wiley&SonsInc,1998.6.
[9] Price M,Martin Lewis.The reinvention of cultural geography.Annals of the Association of American Geographers,1993,83(1):1～17.
[10] 美国国家研究院地学、环境与资源委员会地球科学与资源局重新发现地理学委员会编.黄润华译.重新发现地理学:与科学和社会的新关联.北京:学苑出版社,2002.28～50.
[11] H.J.德伯里著.王民等译.人文地理:文化,社会与空间.北京:北京师范大学出版社,1988.
[12] National Research Council,Rediscovering Geography:New Relevance for Science and Society.Washington D.C.:National A2cademy Press,1997.
[13] Peach C.Social geography:new religions and ethnoburbs contracts with cultural geography.Progress in Human Geography,2002,26(2):252～260.
[14] Cosgrove D.Social Formation and Symbolic Landscape.London:Croom Helm,1988.
[15] Daniels S1Marxism,culture and the duplicity of landscape.In:Angnew J,Livingstone D N,Rogers A.(eds.)Human Geogra2phy:An Essential Anthology.Cambridge Mass:Blackwell,1996.331～340.
[16] MaDowell Linda.The transformation of cultural geography.In:Dereck Gregory,Ron Martin and Graham Smith(eds.)HumanGeography:Society,Space and Social Science.Houndmills:The Macmillan Press LTD,1994.146～173
[17]
[英]安东尼.吉登斯.社会的构成.上海:生活.读书.新知三联书店,1998.514.
[18] 阎小培,林初升,许学强编著.地理.区域.城市———永无止境的探索.广州:广东高等教育出版社,1994.27.
[19] Foucault Michel.Questions on geography.In C Gordon.Power/Knowledge:Selected Interview and Other Vritings 197221977.New York:Pantheon Books,1980.63～77.
[20] Curry M R.On space and spatial practice in contemporary geography.In:Carville Earle,Knet Mathewson&Martin S.Kenzer(eds.)Concepts in Human Geography.US:Rowman&Littlefield Publishing,1995.3～32.
[21]
[英]大卫.哈维著.高泳源等译.地理学中的解释.北京:商务印书馆,1996.231～275.
[22] Haggett P.Geography:A Modern Synthesis.3rd edition.New York:Harpe&Row Publishers,1979.19.
[23] 王志弘.空间与社会:迈向社会优位的空间理论.选自王志弘.流动、空间与社会199121997论文选.台湾:田园城市文化事业,1998.1～16.
[24]
[英]齐格蒙特.鲍曼著.欧阳根景译.流动的现代性.上海:上海三联书店,2002.
[25] 刘本培,蔡运龙主编.地球科学导论.北京:高等教育出版社,2000.4.
[26] Soja.Postmodern Geographies:The Reassertion of Space in Critical Social Theory.London:Verso,1989.
[27]
[奥]卡林.诺尔2塞蒂纳.制造知识———建构主义与科学的与境性.北京:东方出版社,2001.
[28] Wagnar P L.Forward:cultural geography:thirty years of advance.In:Kenneth Foote,Peter Hugill,Kent Mathewson andJonathan Smith(eds.)Re2reading Cultural Geography.Austin:University of Texas Press,1994.3～8.
[29] Ryan J R.History and philosophy of geography 199922000.Progress in Human Geography,2002,26(1):76～89.
[30] Barnett C.The cultural turn:fashion or progress in human geography.Antipode,1998,30(4):379～394.
[31] Crang M.Image2reality.In:Paul Cloke,Philip Crang and Mark Goodwin(eds.),Introducing Human Geographie.London:Arnold,2002.54～61.
[32]
[美]沃尔特.李普曼。阎克文,江红译.公众舆论.上海:上海人民出版社,2002.
[33] 张国良主编.传播学原理.上海:复旦大学出版社,1995.
[34] 韩少功.暗示.北京:人民文学出版社,2002.3801
[35] Crang M.Cultural Geography.London:Roultledge,1998.
[36] Burgess J,John R.Gold(eds.)Geography,The Media and Popular Culture.London:Croom Helm,1985.1～32.
[37] Burgess J.The production and consumption of environmental meanings in the mass media:a research agenda for the 1990s.Trans.Inst.Bri.Geogr.,1990,N.S.15:139～161.
/
| 〈 |
|
〉 |