转型期城市低收入邻里的类型、特征和产生机制:以南京市为例
收稿日期: 2005-12-27
修回日期: 2006-03-20
网络出版日期: 2006-12-15
基金资助
The British Higher Education Link Project(SHA/992/313)和The British Academy Larger GrantScheme(LRG-37484)项目支持
Typology,features and mechanism of urban low-income neighborhoods under market transition:a case study of Nanjing
Received date: 2005-12-27
Revised date: 2006-03-20
Online published: 2006-12-15
本文以南京市为例,检查转型期城市贫困人口的空间分布特征,并着重分析贫困人口集中的低收入邻里的类型、特征及其产生机制。研究表明,转型期我国城市贫困人口的空间分布表现为在邻里或社区层面上的集中。城市贫困人口在邻里层次上的集聚,导致三种类型低收入邻里的产生,包括老城衰退邻里、退化的工人新村和农民工集聚区(城中村)。分析表明,这些低收入邻里的产生源于国家导向的城市发展政策和国家福利住房供应制度,并在住房市场化和房地产导向的城市发展过程中得以强化。基于南京市的实证分析和实地调查,城市贫困人口的空间分布状况和低收入邻里的特征被检查,低收入邻里的产生机制得以验证。
刘玉亭, 吴缚龙, 何深静, 李志刚 . 转型期城市低收入邻里的类型、特征和产生机制:以南京市为例[J]. 地理研究, 2006 , 25(6) : 1073 -1082 . DOI: 10.11821/yj2006060014
Although there is a dispute about whether the spatial concentration of poverty is a major cause of social problems,concentrated poverty' was a rapidly spreading phenomenon in many western cities has come to a broad consensus.Since the market transition of economic system in the early 1990s,urban poverty has become a prominent social problem and attracted some attention among Chinese officials and academics.However,there have been few studies on the spatial features of urban poverty.The purpose of this paper is to examine the spatial distribution of urban poverty in transitional China and in turn to explore the typology,features and creation mechanism of low-income neighborhoods.The research reveals that,the spatial distribution of urban poverty is dispersed at a city-wide level but concentrated in specific neighborhoods.Specifically,three types of low-income neighborhoods have emerged in urban China,which are the old-city dilapidated residence,the degraded worker's village and rural migrants' enclaves.The research further argues that the emergence of low-income neighborhood is rooted in the state-led urban development policy and the socialist housing provision system,and is intensified by the housing marketization and real estate-led urban development.Based on the analysis and field survey of typical low-income neighborhoods in Nanjing city,the spatial distribution of poverty and the features of low-income neighborhoods are examined,and the creation mechanism of low-income neighborhoods is validated.Further discussion indicates that low-income neighborhoods in urban China are different from the slum or ghetto in advanced Western cities.
Key words： urban poverty; low-income neighborhood; typology; mechanism; Nanjing
[1] Badcock B. Rest ruct uring and spatial polarization in cities. Progress in Human Geograp hy,1997,21(2):251～262.
[2] Mingione E. U rban povert y in t he advanced indust rial world:concept s,analysis and debates. In:Mingione E(ed.).U rban Povert y and t he Underclass. Oxford:Blackwell,1996.
[3] Mingione E1 The new urban povert y and t he underclass:int roduction1 International Journal of Urban and RegionResearch,1993,17:324～326.
[4] Kempen E T V. The dual cit y and t he poor:social polarisation,social segregation and life chances. Urban St udies,1994,31(7):995～1015.
[5] Marcuse P. Space and race in t he po st2Fordist cit y. In:Mingione E(ed.).Urban Povert y and The Underclass. Ox2ford:Blackwell,1996.
[6] McCulloch A1 Ward2level deprivation and individual social and econo mic outco mes in t he British Household PanelSt udy1 Environment and Planning A,2001,33:667～684.
[7] Orfield M. Met ropolitics:A Regional Agenda for Communit y and Stabilit y. Washington,D C:The Broo kings Insti2t ution and t he Lincoln Instit ute of Land Policy11998.
[8] Wilson W J. When Work Disappears:The World of t he New Urban Poor. New York:Rando m House. 1996.
[9] Crump J. Deconcent ration by demolition:p ublic housing,povert y,and urban policy1 Environment and PlanningD:Societ y and Space,2002,20:581～596.
[10] Carter W H,Schill M H,Wachter S M. Polarisation,public housing and racial minorities in U S cities. Urban St ud-ies,1998,35:1889～1911.
[11] Wacquant L J D. Three pernicious p remises in t he st udy of t he American ghet to. International Journal of Urban andRegional Research,1997,21:341～353.
[12] Wu F L. Urban povert y and marginalization under market t ransition:t he case of Chinese cities. International Jour2nal of Urban and Regional Research,2004,28(2):401～23.
[13] Liu Y T,Wu F L. The state,instit utional t ransition and t he creation of new urban povert y in China. Social Policyand Administ ration,2006,40(2):121～137.
[14] 马清裕,等.北京城市贫困人口特征、成因及其解困对策,地理研究,1999,18(4):400～406.
[15] 柴彦威.以单位为基础的中国城市内部生活空间结构—兰州市的实证研究.地理研究,1996,15(1):30～37.
[16] Wang Y P,Murie A. Social and spatial implications of housing reform in China. International Journal of Urban andRegional Research,2000,24(2):397～417.
[17] 顾朝林,Kestloot C.北京社会极化与空间分异研究1地理学报,1997,(5):385～393.
[18] 吴启焰.城市社会空间分异的研究领域及其进展.城市规划汇刊,1999,(3):23～26.
[19] 饶小军,邵晓光.边缘社区:城市簇群社会空间透视.城市规划,2001,(9):47～51.
[20] 徐晓军1我国城市社区走向阶层化的实证分析1城市发展研究,2000,(4):31～33.
[21] Wu F L. Socio spatial differentiation in urban China:evidence f ro m Shanghai’s real estate market s. Environmentaland Planning A,2002,34:1591～1615.
[22] 许学强,等.广州市社会空间的因子生态分析.地理学报,1989,44(4):385～397.
[23] 郑静,等.广州市社会空间的因子生态再分析.地理研究,1995,14(2):15～25.
[24] 艾大宾,王力.我国城市社会空间结构的特征及其演变趋势.人文地理,2001,(2):7～11.
[25] 修春亮,夏长金.中国城市社会区域的形成过程与发展趋势.城市规划汇刊,1997,(4):59～62.
[26] Zhang L,Simon X B,Tian J P. Self2help in housing and Chengzhongcun in China’s urbanization1 International Jour2nal of Urban and Regional Research,2003,27(4):912～937.
[27] MacDonald H. Comment on Sandra J Newman and Ann B Schnare’s And a suitable living environment’:t he failureof housing p rograms to deliver on neighborhood qualit y. Housing Policy Debate,1997,8:755～762.
[28] Galster G,Zobel A1 Will dispersed housing p rogrammes reduce social problems in t he U S?Housing St udies,1998,13:605～622.
[29] Greenstone J D. Cult ure,rationalit y,and t he underclass. In:J encks C,Peterson P E(eds.).The U rbanU nderclass. Washington,D. C.:The Brookings Institution,1991.
/
| 〈 |
|
〉 |