民国29~35年(1940~1946年),国民政府对川黔交界地区的插花地进行了清理拨正。清理拨正可大别为两个阶段:一是川黔两省自行清理拨正(1940~1944年),二是内政部主持下的清理拨正(1945~1946年)。清理拨正成效较为明显,不仅进行了实地会勘,而且形成了会议决议,川黔交界地区8县17乡镇的33个插花地问题在这次清理拨正中得到了较为合理的解决。但由于狭隘的地方保护主义思想、对插花地的认识理解难以完全统一等因素的影响,清理拨正同样很不彻底,不仅存在不少遗留问题,而且遗漏颇多。研究这次清理拨正,对推动插花地研究的深入发展、总结清理拨正插花地的经验教训、较好解决当前的插花地遗留问题等都有重要意义。
The government of the Republic of China made cleaning-up and mending on the enclaves in the border area between Sichuan and Guizhou in the years 29-35 during the period of the Republic of China (1940-1946). This work can be divided into two stages: in the first stage, the two provinces did the cleaning-up and mending in 1940-1944; in the second the work was done under the auspices of the Internal Affairs Ministry of the Republic of China in 1945-1946. The effects of the work were very obvious. Field surveys were made and some resolutions were achieved after conferences. Thirty-three problems were solved, which were associated with the enclaves involving 8 counties, 17 villages and towns in the border area between Sichuan and Guizhou. However, due to the impact of the local protectionism, the lack of knowledge of enclaves and different viewpoints of enclaves, the tasks were not completed yet. There were not only some problems remaining unsolved, but also many of them were not taken into consideration. The study of the cleaning-up and mending process will play an important role in strengthening the enclave study, summarizing the experiences in cleaning-up and mending the enclaves and solving the remaining unsolved problems of enclaves.
[1] 周振鹤.中国行政区划通史(总论、先秦卷).上海:复旦大学出版社,2009.
[2] 刘君德,靳润成,周克瑜.中国政区地理.北京:科学出版社,1999.
[3] 王恩涌.中国政治地理.北京:科学出版社,2004.
[4] 侯景新,蒲善新,肖金成.行政区划与区域管理.北京:中国人民大学出版社,2006.
[5] 浦善新.中国行政区划改革研究.北京:商务印书馆,2006.
[6] 李晓杰.体国经野——历代行政区划.长春:长春出版社,2004.
[7] 贵州省地方志编纂委员会.贵州省志·地理志(上册).贵阳:贵州人民出版社,1985.
[8] 杨斌.历史时期西南"插花"初探.西南师范大学学报: 哲学社会科学版,1999,(1):35~40.
[9] 傅辉.插花地对土地数据的影响及处理方法.中国社会经济史研究,2004,(2):20~28.
[10] 傅辉.河南插花地个案研究(1368~1953年).中国地理学会历史地理专业委员会《历史地理》编委会. 历史地理(19).上海:上海人民出版社,2003.39~47.
[11] 郭声波.飞地行政区的历史回顾与现实实践的探讨.江汉论坛,2006,(1):88~91.
[12] 冯贤亮.疆界错壤:清代"苏南"地方的行政地理及其整合.江苏社会科学,2005,(4):211~217.
[13] 冯贤亮.明代江南的争田问题——以嘉兴府嘉、秀、善三县为中心.中国社会经济史研究,2000,(4):24~37.
[14] 鲁西奇,林昌丈.飞地:孤悬在外的领土.地图,2009,(4):26~33.
[15] 马琦,韩昭庆,孙涛.明清贵州插花地研究.复旦学报: 社会科学版,2010,(6):122~128.
[16] 王开队.13~18 世纪云贵川交界地区政区设置变化趋势研究.中国历史地理论丛,2009,(1):60~67.
[17] 贵州省文史研究馆校勘.(民国)贵州通志·前事志(三).贵阳:贵州人民出版社,1988.178.
[18] 犹海龙,侯树涛,赵元隽.(民国)桐梓县志.张瑞琪,龙砺孚,李明方,夏永忠校点.1987(内部发行).40.
[19] 贵州省文史研究馆校勘.(民国)贵州通志·前事志(三).贵阳:贵州人民出版社,1988.489~490.
[20] 民政部, 等.关于加强行政区域界线管理工作的意见.中华人民共和国国务院公报,2005,(32):12~14.
[21] 国务院. 国务院关于开展勘定省县两级行政区域界线工作有关问题的通知.中华人民共和国国务院公报,1996,(25):967~969.