Evaluation method and empirical study on service quality of seismic emergency shelters
Received date: 2014-03-12
Request revised date: 2014-10-10
Online published: 2014-11-10
Copyright
Effective evaluation on layout and service quality of emergency shelters can make great references for risk reduction and emergency management. However, spatial layout of emergency shelters in urban spaces are quite difficult to be made clear, in particular some open spaces located among multi-storied buildings were usually neglected. This is quite a big problem for evaluation. Our paper firstly proposed an identification model to pick out candidate emergency shelters from concentrated cities based on urban land-use, buildings, and so on. Considering potential risk of topographical features, geographical conditions, and other danger sources, emergency shelters suitable for evacuation were filtered out from those candidate shelters by safety index we built. Secondly, considering the distance and capacity of emergency shelters, accessibility and adequacy model was designed to evaluate service quality of emergency shelters. Finally, all the models were tested in Haidian District, Beijing in China. Several conclusions can be drawn as follows. (1) The layout of emergency shelters and spatial pattern of population distribution cannot match each other in some region, for example, the emergency shelters are quite dispersed in the southeast where the population density is quite high. (2) Many regions were inaccessible in the south of Haidian within 1 minute after earthquake, and these regions reduced highly when it extended to 5 minutes. (3) Compared with the conditions in daytime, the capacity of emergency shelters at night seems worse, especially the Xiaonanzhuang residential area in the middle of Haidian. However, it is quite interesting that some street blocks of higher or lower capacity of emergency shelters have good connectivity with each other. Spatial planning of labeling system of emergency shelters in these blocks in future may play an important role in guiding people towards different shelters, which may improve service equality of emergency shelters.
Key words: emergency shelters; capacity; accessibility; service quality
JI Jue , GAO Xiaolu . Evaluation method and empirical study on service quality of seismic emergency shelters[J]. GEOGRAPHICAL RESEARCH, 2014 , 33(11) : 2105 -2114 . DOI: 10.11821/dlyj201411010
Tab. 1 Construction features of seismic shelters in Beijing表1 北京市震灾避难场所建设的规范特征 |
| 紧急避难场所 | 长期避难场所 | |
|---|---|---|
| 功 能 | 突发灾害时的临时避难 过渡性作用 | 灾后政府集中救助 |
| 面 积 | 不小于2000~3000 m2 或1000米的绿地,操场等 | 4000 m2以上(有效避难面积在60%以上) |
| 人均避难面积 | 1.5~2.0 m2 1.0 m2(四个老城区) | 2.0~3.0 m2 |
| 服务半径 | 500 m(步行5~10 min) | 2000~5000 m(步行0.5~1 h) |
| 规 模 | 面积规模相对小的空地,包括小公园绿地、小花园(游园)、小广场(小健身活动场)等 | 市级、区级公园绿地,各类体育场等,城区边缘地带的空地、城市绿化隔离地区等 |
| 其 他 | 1、避让地震断裂带,远离泄洪区、低洼地易积水地区,高压线走廊区域 2、建筑倒塌范围之外 3、应急厕所、应急供电、无障碍坡道等 4、主要道路宽度大于3.75 m | |
Fig. 1 Calculation of fallen extent of architecture buildings图1 建筑物倒塌范围计算示意 |
Tab. 2 Rectification index of housing structure表2 不同房屋结构的修正参数 |
| 房屋结构 | ai | BFi |
|---|---|---|
| 土木及其他 | 1 | 0.64 H |
| 砖木 | 0.95 | 0.61 H |
| 混合 | 0.9 | 0.58 H |
| 钢混 | 0.6 | 0.38 H |
Tab. 3 Evaluation index of safety表3 安全性评价的指标体系 |
| 一级指标 | 二级指标 | 指标参考值 |
|---|---|---|
| 环境安全性 | 与加油站、加气站的位置关系 | 50 m以外 |
| 与化工厂的位置关系 | 50 m以外 | |
| 地质安全性 | 与地质断层的位置关系 | 断裂带周边30 m避让 |
| 是否处于低洼积水区域 | 否 |
Fig. 2 Distribution of seismic shelters in Haidian District图2 海淀区紧急避难场所的空间分布 |
Fig. 3 Seismic shelters and their accessibility in Haidian District图3 海淀区紧急避难场所服务可达范围分布 |
Fig. 4 Evaluation of adequacy of seismic shelters in Haidian District图4 海淀区避难场所充实度的评价结果 |
The authors have declared that no competing interests exist.
| [1] |
[
|
| [2] |
[
|
| [3] |
|
| [4] |
[
|
| [5] |
[
|
| [6] |
[
|
| [7] |
[
|
| [8] |
|
| [9] |
|
| [10] |
|
| [11] |
|
| [12] |
[
|
| [13] |
[
|
| [14] |
[
|
| [15] |
[
|
| [16] |
[
|
| [17] |
[
|
| [18] |
[
|
| [19] |
|
| [20] |
[
|
| [21] |
[
|
| [22] |
[
|
| [23] |
[
|
/
| 〈 |
|
〉 |