The herding husbandry peoples in the northern Shanxi and Shaanxi provinces and the macro human geographical structure of northern China during the Pre-Qin times
Received date: 2003-03-20
Revised date: 2003-06-30
Online published: 2011-02-25
During the period of pre Qin dynasty, there were groups of people, called Rong(戎)and Di(狄), in the northern Shanxi and Shaanxi provinces, who were not the same kind of nomadic people as Xiongnu (Hun) since they lived in a mixed style of economic situation, half herding and half agricultural. But, in the traditional documents of the dynastic times, these groups of people have been described as the same kind of nomadic people like Xiongnu, some were even identified as the ancestors of Xiongnu. The misunderstanding of the identity of Rong and Di caused misunderstanding of the region where the Rong and Di lived. According to the traditional idea, the environment of the region of the northern Shanxi and Shaanxi had, as well as the steppe, supported nomadic life. The essential different ecological functions in early civilization creation between the environment of the northern Shanxi/Shaanxi and the environment of the steppe, therefore, were neglected. The recent archaeologist discoveries show that the life indicated by the settlement ruins, tombs, and life remains of Rong and Di people has been more a sedentary style, which had been combined with partly agricultural and partly herding activities. The archaeologist discoveries also show that before the Rong and Di times, the region of the northern Shanxi/Shaanxi had been occupied by a well developed prim agricultural economy. Since the climate changed colder about 5000 years ago, the herding activity developed significantly, and the pure prim agricultural economy was replaced by half agricultural and half herding. The Rong and Di, therefore, was not the representative group of nomadic in northern ancient China. The true nomadic people, which was represented by Xiongnu, appeared later than Rong and Di in China. The question of the origin of nomadic economy in China should be considered more with the Xiongnu instead of the Rong and Di. Since the recognition of the independent identity of the Rong and Di, the macro human geographical structure of the northern China then should consist of three great regions: the region of the Rong and Di, the standard agricultural region in the south where the Han people were living, and the typical steppe nomadic region in the north where the Xiongnu became occupiers.
Key words: nomadism; Hun(Xiongnu); northern China
TANG Xiao feng . The herding husbandry peoples in the northern Shanxi and Shaanxi provinces and the macro human geographical structure of northern China during the Pre-Qin times[J]. GEOGRAPHICAL RESEARCH, 2003 , 22(5) : 618 -624 . DOI: 10.11821/yj2003050010
[1] 冯家升.匈奴民族及其文化.见:禹贡半月刊,1937,7(5):21~34.文中以为这三十多种称呼都是匈奴的别名.
[2] 王国维.鬼方昆夷Ν狁考1见:观堂集林.卷十三.北京:中华书局,1959.583~605.
[3] 林旅芝,编.匈奴史.香港:香港中华文化事业公司,1963.26.此书引王国维《鬼方昆夷Ν狁考》,并引梁启超《国史研究》六篇中的列表,将古代各类戎狄都归为匈奴.
[4] 刘学铫.匈奴史论.台北:南天书局,1987.
[5] 林干.匈奴通史.北京:人民出版社,1986.书中注意到戎狄与匈奴的区别,但忽略了其间的社会形态差异和地理区域变化.
[6] 翁独健,主编.中国民族关系史纲要.北京:中国社会科学出版社,1990.76.
[7] 徐仲舒.北狄在前殷文化上之贡献:论殷墟青铜器与两轮大车之由来.见:古今论衡.1999,(3):171~200.本文为徐仲舒先生遗稿,写作年代是1948年,引文见175,177.
[8] 拉铁摩尔.中国的边疆.赵敏求译.正中书局,1941.第11章.翻译词句有改动.
[9] 江上波夫.古代北方文化.东京:山川出版社,1948.转引自杜正胜(见
[14] ),294~295.
[10] 林 .关于中国的对匈奴族源的考古研究.见:林 学术文集1北京:中国大百科全书出版社,1998.365~3861引文见369.
[11] 田广金.朱开沟.北京:文物出版社,2000.
[12] 张映文,吕智荣.陕西清涧县李家崖古城址发掘简报.考古与文物,1988,(1):47~56.
[13] 韩茂莉.农牧交错带的形成与气候变迁.北京大学历史地理研究中心编.侯仁之师九十寿辰纪念文集.北京:学苑出版社,2003.151~166.引文见151.
[14] 杜正胜.欧亚草原动物纹饰与中国古代北方民族之考察.台北:中央研究院历史语言研究所集刊.1993,第64本,第2分,231~408.引文见303.
[15] 郭沫若.小盂鼎.见:两周金文辞大系图录考释.上海:上海书店,1999.
/
| 〈 |
|
〉 |